There is a version of the anchovy that has spent thirty years ruining the anchovy’s reputation in America: gray, hairy, aggressively salty, smeared across a Caesar with apology. Ortiz is the rebuttal. These are anchoas del Cantábrico — caught in the spring off the northern coast of Spain, salt-matured in the Basque Country for the better part of two years, then hand-filleted one fish at a time. The price reflects the labor, and the labor reflects in the fish.

Tasting notes

Appearance
Long, even fillets the color of polished rosewood, laid in formation in a clean, pale oil. No silverskin, no stray bones, no bruising. They look filleted by someone who cared.
Aroma
Clean sea and cured meat — closer to a good jamón than to anything fishy. The brine is present but disciplined.
Texture
Silken and yielding, never mushy. The fillet holds its shape on the fork and then gives way completely on the tongue. This is what the extra curing months buy you.
Flavor
Bright, deeply savory, faintly sweet at the back. The salt is integrated rather than dominant, and the finish is long and oil-slicked in the best sense. Umami without aggression.

What separates Ortiz from the supermarket tin is restraint at every stage. The oil is a frame, not a flavor — a pale olive oil chosen to stay out of the way. The salt cure is long enough to deepen the fish without curing it into jerky. The fillet work is precise enough that you are never picking a pin bone out of your teeth mid-bite. None of these are flashy decisions. Together they are the entire game.

Is sixteen dollars a lot for a 47-gram tin? In the abstract, yes. In practice, this is roughly the cost of a cocktail you will forget, and it produces eight to ten of the best single bites available in American grocery delivery. Lay one fillet on buttered toast with a few flakes of salt and you will understand why the Spanish treat the good anchovy as a delicacy rather than a topping.

The verdict

9.4 / 10 Editor’s Choice

The reference-standard Cantabrian anchovy for American buyers, and the tin we measure every other anchovy against. Buy it once and recalibrate your expectations permanently.

Where to buy

These are affiliate links. We may earn a commission if you buy through them, at no additional cost to you. We bought this tin at retail with our own money.

As an Amazon Associate, The Tin Guide earns from qualifying purchases.